events at ®eduxView events listed alphabeticallyView list of guests & artistscontact ®edux
Merz: curated by Peter Lewis
Took place: July 21st 2006, 8.00 pm, at Magazin4     [ Photos ]
Organised by Wolfgang Fetz Director at Magazin4

Merz Location: Magazin4,
Bregenzer Kunstverein,
Bergmannstra├če 6, A-6900 Bregenz

T +43 (0)5574 410 1523
F +43 (0)5574 410 550

Press Release
Migrations of the Merzbau

It's too hot. The inner city is a sweat-box. All the books are packed. On the move again. The artist cannot afford the landlord's rent, so must inevitably migrate. Where to this time? The council houses, squats, bed sits, and all the bad housing are full with artists and refugees, conjoined as the poorest sector of the urban populace. Nowhere to go, yet everywhere to run to, making do with things at hand and 'forging' our art on the run. We are all refugees and artists here. Leyton is popular and cheap. Everything is moveable in the evacuated zone, on the edges of London, rich in nationalities passing through, settling for a time, moving on. Alfred Hitchcock was born and raised here before migrating to Hollywood with Sigmund Freud under his belt. What starts as one thing becomes many others, so as to forget the memory of the original 'cause'. How did we get here? Its real, this place, but not an easy transition to make from the other side. Like the Book of the Dead, it's an underworld passage that tests human endurance. And all this 'stuff' to go too. All the home-made shelving, bits and pieces, the dusty books set in varnish, the stained, dust ingrained sheets used for canvas, toe clippings kept for sentimental reasons, the newspapers kept in crates, broken TVs, throwaway cameras, paint tins, bottled residues shining like gold, half-finished collages and half- drunk wine, the threatening notes eloquently written to the neighbours and landlord, the cat, all the garbage bags full of bus tickets and collected supermarket receipts - money spent recklessly on nothing worthwhile. And More. The solicitor's bills. The cans of air freshener, souvenirs, salvaged postcards from my dead father, a scribbled manuscript about Kurt Schwitters, stacks of 'fizzled out' drawings, all unfinished. A great breathing accumulate of rubbish is coming to Life, resembling the Great Accumulate in situ: Pure Mass, heavier than earth, the converse of Plato's Ideal. But there's an inexistent Quality hovering above it all. Intangible, like an unseen eye directing the movements of a fly circling in rising heat, is the Idea.

No, in fact I know what it is. It's MERZ! Kurt Schwitters hardly knew what would endure of his unseen great work; an exquisite can of worms opening up the present, and spilling itself everywhere.

We, the clandestine martyrs of Merz may be the last vestige of an old avant-garde [the multitudes of an elite] to emerge as the new avant-garde of the Third Space [as defined by Fanon, as sharing the borders of and exposing the trespass of the First and Second worlds] by living absolutely within the 'episteme' of a new Global Order. And this inverted naturalisation of the military term means we are all in some way or another discrete as an avant-garde, [to be mobilised] since it is no longer tenable to romanticise a neutral or 'equidistant' pose, if breathing the same 'political' air as the refugee. No time for philosophical musing. As Slavov Zizek writes to resituate the maxim: don't throw the baby out with the dirty water, keep the dirty water, throw out the baby. Schwitter's may have laughed out loud at this revelation.

The fugitive, material, and localised space engendered of Merz in various incarnations have expanded the contemporary field of a common understanding. Curating turns into 'merzing', invoking the early specific and exemplary models from Modernism. The Expressionist [the dark, or sinister, if you like, the 'noir'] and its transverse [the utopic] are amended from a Constructivist and Futurist romance with the machine. Visions such as theirs are destitute when immersed in the 'dirty water' of a global contemporary consciousness. All can 'share' the event, whether football, or battle at the same global time. Heraclitus' infamous fragment, that the best view of a battle will be judged from a distance, takes on new echoes of a permanent state of embattlement, waged in the 'cool' ether incubating images of torture and genocide]. The 'artistically' edited video works produced at Abu Ghraib, test the artist's iconoclastic/reflexive critique of the populist image and therefore cannot compete with the iconphilic nature of the terrorist's synthetic 'shared' use of the apparatus of representation. Video space, rather than the white cube space, becomes the ultimate weapon of techno-culture. Revolution beckons as differentiation lessens and the embers of duration are finally extinguished.

The Merz is an object without boundaries, aleatory, accidental, and sprawling. Its anti-architecture 'environment' is not a literal 'filling up' of space but a new concept of political space or 'platform', as we must acknowledge, which is already with us. The transversatile appearance and disappearance of the Merzbau, as it was constructed, reconstructed, destroyed and then re-made (though never completed) provides us with a very suggestive point of reference for our own contemporary discourse, the 'dispositif' (to take a term from Jean-Francois Lyotard), or 'how it is'. The 'dispositif' is a set-up, like a trap. Dada used the snare of an 'unexpected' effect like this, setting up expectation and delivering a blow directly to it. The polemic was integral. Historical evaluation of the early avant-garde may forget this infra-structural necessity. In the ashes of a specific model of an avant-garde 'dispositif' a new experience may begin by initialising a trajectory from Dada by inviting artists to occupy spaces to work to assemble structures in close proximity, or to dislocate structures in the streets of the city that perform as interpolations [i.e. interrupting a shared cognition of common or public space with 'foreign' matter].

The 'dispositif' is at once Merz: civic, embodied in diverse, collected, residual objects, not as signifying the archaeology of a life or lives, but as a real process of a difficult democratic principle, to be found and formed out of material disjuncture. This is the art or the practice of the everyday. It transforms our traditional concepts of the 'collaged' image, destroying it and deserting it, extending it into space and time, and redefining it as an arena of action. This occurs at the level of 'display' and as 'detournement'. As a tool, Merz negates the traditional media of memory and representation, [after Stalinism / Hitlerism and Fascism it is impossible, now with an unprecedented, unlawful Americanism, to believe in the unity of any social perception from a single point perspective of knowledge, whatever field]. This revolution, notable in the practice of Merz, exchanges the transformation of formal representational systems for the transformation of the means and materials of representation. The practice anticipates the discourse to be assembled in the severity of its [self] criticisms, that first there is absolute defeat in the face of the conditions in which it may arise. The 'dispositif' is not just a representation of mental processes deposited in museums as a synecdoche of the past, or the present, as 'facts' but much more a 'set up' of affects and fictions that disable the reality traps set by a dubious authority. Schwitters would, I believe, welcome the return of such a resistant strain in art practice and discourse, with a shrug, as if to say 'don't believe a word of it'.

However, writes Peter Weibel, assuming that the avant-garde movements from 1950 to 1970 share the same epistemic field as the cultural theories of their time, from semiotics to psychoanalysis, we can apply these [certain] theories to art movements, to produce new interpretations of that period.[1] And the present one no less so. He continues to claim that the neo-avant-garde was a political art, not at the level of representation, but at the level of the dispositif. The reappearance of Merz-structures in the current climate of change finds the Merzbau everywhere, at a horizontal, rather than vertical plane, evidence of a profound boredom (the stuff of art), its haunting form arising out of domestic and urban commonality. As with the vernacular of 'do it yourself' architectures, Merz embodies the dialogical process of constructing, destroying and reconstructing things, reconstituting the works' intricate layers to the point where what remains is defiant, resilient yet fluid, or, its entry being difficult, secreted on the margins, as 'heterotopic' architecture.

Schwitters constructed three versions of the Merzbau (which he also described as his 'cathedral of erotic misery'), the first in his family home in Hanover, Germany (1920s), the second in Lysaker, Norway (1937 - 40), and finally in Elterwater in Britain's Lake District (1948). The substantial but incomplete remains of the third Merzbau are now preserved at the University of Newcastle (UK). Schwitters' refugee itinerary took him from Nazi Germany through Europe and into Britain. The Merzbau, although complicated and time-consuming in their production, concern the loss of stability as much as they are simultaneously a striving towards that. Schwitters' status as a wartime refugee cannot but be echoed in his artistic practice, which itself, greatly dependent upon the accumulation of stray and disregarded materials, implies a constant - but always constantly frustrated tendency towards coherence and resolution.

The Merzbau is further distinguished by its approximation of totalisation, Wagner's notion of the Gesamtkunstwerk being pertinent here. As a model of a 'total artwork', an accumulation of multiple and often contrasting elements, containing within itself biographical and autobiographical fragments, the Merzbau is a paradigmatic object with respect to its influence upon the 'expanded field' (Rosalind Krauss) of current artistic practice.

The multiple, differentiated inheritances of Schwitters' Merzbau, not least with regard to the related 'principles' of Dada, the itinerant, and the hidden or secretly preserved operate through chance: accident and random circumstance provide an index of a personal state of change in angst (the now naturalised urban condition). Merz and the Merzbau are the exemplary models for our sense of being modern, for the complexities and contradictions which result from migrations, wars, of which our current situation, as 'dispositif' is composed.

I think the Merzbau of today is a kind of limitless object. That the re-appearance of these messy, noisy assemblages, are evidence, in their sense of a disengaged Real, a stubborn devise as effective as Diogenes' barrel had been to proclaim utter disbelief in authority and its grand narratives: these 'machinic assemblages', [a geo-political term from Deleuze & Guattari] or 'cathedrals of erotic misery' [Schwitter's term] are symptomatic of a condition of an heroic isolation which celebrates reification, to be privileged in the object as fetish. The early modernist romance that engaged Dada made an elegy of indifferences into a political act. It ennobled the small and the found in the collages, assemblages and sound poems of Schwitters to re-set the 'beat' of a new synaesthetic art, played on the hallucinatory percussion heard in everyday city life, as its base material; Schwitter's 'concrete' poetry and assemblage is played counter-point to the prosaic conceits found in Georges Bataille's 'evil' residues of literature, in titles like 'The Sex Crime Cave', 'Grotto of Love', 'Cave of Murderers', 'Cave of Depreciated Heroes' or even we conjecture, to include again 'Plato's Cave' which takes on another reading on the same material plane as other caves - suggesting that built-in systems of value, and models of behaviour, like their environments, are always subject to change.

Merz is a human space that wills itself within the absent centre of the political, as a location or a 'home', nest, cave or sanctuary. In fitting Dada spirit Schwitters chose to live, during his period of internment in a prisoner of war camp under a table. But the human properties that are unsullied in Merz structures are also evidence of the dislocation of culture, multiplying an 'original' multiple [the Merz structure, as an organic / architectural object is an 'incomplete' project]. Artists make a [vain] attempt to rescue the idea of the enlightened thinking through rational questioning of ideas overtaken by the inhumanism of technological progression, by situating the Merz as a terra-firma wherever it begins again. The generosity of the Merz is in providing the world an approximation of its conditions, growing the way things or cities themselves grow in chaos. There are only the reports of eye-witnesses to the 1923-43 Merzbau. The photographs have replaced experience. The photograph now itself in excelis represents the unrepresentable as already - no longer existent 'merz'. The king is dead, long live the king! This says much about the 'world' in our own time, about our sense of humanity and the continuing story of the Merzbau as our own lurid song, an arrhythmic heart beat through History's dissonant body.

Could Merz present the modern as a 'not giving up' the fairy tale of 'humanity' itself, as it begins to disappear from our comprehension? Schwitters set laughter along with his Dada peers as a strategy and tactic to escape the banality of evil by ridicule and confrontation - desiring machines, theatrical traps, confidence tricks or set-ups, etcetera. Is it not the same trap that incites the grand illusion of childhood where myth and fact so easily subsume together, playing 'let's pretend' in the home's grottos and caves that is stolen by ideology in order to persecute? There is more to the wonder of discovering something 'dirty' in any Merz structure.

Although Schwitters himself distanced himself from any Universalist motivation, Merz is in 'spirit' both emptying of meaning, so as to be filled to the pinnacle with the messy and noisy void of the everyday. This is the very essence of becoming Merz, a rational process of both staking a claim to axiom and theorem, and of the paradox of the Merz: our 'inexistence' at the heart of the Real.

[1] from Peter Weibel, 'Re-presentation of the Repressed: The Political Revolution of the Neo-avant-garde' in Radical Philosophy a journal of socialist and feminist philosophy, issue 137, May/June 2006, p20.
Migrations of the Merzbau,
® Peter Lewis 2006.

[ Events ]

For further information contact:
Bregenzer Kunstverein,
Bergmannstra├če 6, A-6900 Bregenz

T +43 (0)5574 410 1523
F +43 (0)5574 410 550

Download as a PDF